2025 Action Scorecards

Question · Action Scorecards 2025

Does the council require a fabric first approach for new development?

Question code
3.3b
Section
Planning & Land Use
Topic
New Homes - Energy Efficiency Requirements
Source
Volunteer Research
Question weight
Medium

Criteria

The criteria will be met by English councils if they have a policy that exceeds the minimum government's building regulations on the Part L Target for Fabric Energy Efficiency.

Alternatively, the criteria will be met for councils that have a policy with a space heating requirement that exceeds the minimum government's building regulations.

For Scottish councils, the criteria will be met if the council requires developers to meet the Silver or Gold building standards.

Clarifications

The Part L target for Fabric Energy Efficiency defines the efficiency of the building fabric, which includes the U-values, air tightness and thermal bridging - the parts of the building that lose heat.

A fabric first approach by a council would require improvements on the national standard thereby ensuring new homes are energy efficient.

When marking the Planning section we will assess a Regulation 19 draft local plan or the latest adopted Local Plan or Supplementary Planning Document from the council.

Question performance

Or show scores by type of council

0 points

139 district councils

1 point

25 district councils

Performance comparison between 2023 and 2025

district councils

66
councils scored higher in 2025
1919
councils scored lower in 2025

Legends for difference column

-- No change
NA New question (not in previous scorecards)
CouncilScoreDifference2023Evidence
Cheltenham Borough Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
City of Lincoln Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
East Cambridgeshire District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Epping Forest District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Folkestone and Hythe District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Hertsmere Borough Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Lancaster City Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Malvern Hills District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
New Forest District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
▲ 1

Evidence

1/1▲ 1
North Kesteven District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Rother District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
▲ 1

Evidence

1/1▲ 1
Runnymede Borough Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
▲ 1

Evidence

1/1▲ 1
South Oxfordshire District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
▲ 1

Evidence

1/1▲ 1
South Staffordshire Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Uttlesford District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
▲ 1

Evidence

1/1▲ 1
Vale of White Horse District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Warwick District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Waverley Borough Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Wealden District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
▲ 1

Evidence

1/1▲ 1
West Lancashire Borough Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
West Lindsey District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
West Oxfordshire District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Winchester City Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Worcester City Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Wychavon District Council
Score 2025
1/1
2023 Difference
--

Evidence

1/1--
Adur District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Amber Valley Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Arun District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Ashfield District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Ashford Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Babergh District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Basildon Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Bassetlaw District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Blaby District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Bolsover District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Borough of Broxbourne
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Boston Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Braintree District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Breckland District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Brentwood Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Broadland District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Bromsgrove District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Broxtowe Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Burnley Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Cambridge City Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Cannock Chase District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Canterbury City Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Castle Point Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Charnwood Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Chelmsford City Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1No evidence found
Cherwell District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Chesterfield Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Chichester District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Chorley Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Colchester Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Cotswold District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Crawley Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Dacorum Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Dartford Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Derbyshire Dales District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Dover District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Eastbourne Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
East Devon District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
East Hampshire District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
East Hertfordshire District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Eastleigh Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
East Lindsey District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
East Staffordshire Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
East Suffolk Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1No evidence found
Elmbridge Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1No evidence found
Epsom and Ewell Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Erewash Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Exeter City Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Fareham Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Fenland District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Forest of Dean District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Fylde Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Gedling Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Gloucester City Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Gosport Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Gravesham Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Great Yarmouth Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Guildford Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1No evidence found
Harborough District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Harlow Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Hart District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Hastings Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Havant Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
High Peak Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Hinckley and Bosworth Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Horsham District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Huntingdonshire District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Hyndburn Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Ipswich Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
King's Lynn and West Norfolk Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Lewes District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Lichfield District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Maidstone Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Maldon District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Mansfield District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Melton Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Mid Devon District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Mid Suffolk District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Mid Sussex District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Mole Valley District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Newark and Sherwood District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Newcastle-Under-Lyme District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
North Devon Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
North East Derbyshire District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
North Hertfordshire District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
North Norfolk District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
North Warwickshire Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
North West Leicestershire District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Norwich City Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Nuneaton and Bedworth Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Oadby and Wigston Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Oxford City Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Pendle Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Preston City Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Redditch Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Reigate & Banstead Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Ribble Valley Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Rochford District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Rossendale Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Rugby Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Rushcliffe Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Rushmoor Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Sevenoaks District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
South Cambridgeshire District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
South Derbyshire District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
South Hams District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
South Holland District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
South Kesteven District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
South Norfolk District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
South Ribble Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Spelthorne Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Stafford Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1No evidence found
Staffordshire Moorlands District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
St Albans City and District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Stevenage Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Stratford-on-Avon District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Stroud District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Surrey Heath Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Swale Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Tamworth Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Tandridge District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Teignbridge District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Tendring District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Test Valley Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Tewkesbury Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Thanet District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Three Rivers District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Tonbridge and Malling Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Torridge District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Tunbridge Wells Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
▼ 0
0/1▼ -1Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Watford Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Welwyn Hatfield Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
West Devon Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
West Suffolk Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Woking Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Worthing Borough Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--Evidence doesn't meet criteria
Wyre Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found
Wyre Forest District Council
Score 2025
0/1
2023 Difference
--
0/1--No evidence found